Whatever happened to good, old-fashioned imperialism?
Speaking historically, I mean.
We have tens of millions of refugees, mostly men of military age, fleeing their homelands trying to reach northwestern Europe and North America. They are fleeing states that would be complimented to be considered failed states. Places that teach Anarchists errors from which those anarchists could learn much were they to attend to them. Venezuela, El Salvador, Aleppo, Libya, Spanish Sahara, Mali, Darfur, Sudan, Somalia. Can anyone deny that such refugee movements brand these countries as abject failures? There is a scarlet letter, and it is written across these countries in blood.
There is a name for such epic failure and tragedy: Opportunity.
When a company such as American Motors fails, we do not burn it to the ground and euthanise the employees. Different people take over the land and buildings and hire workers. Who will take over Venezuela? Water, good soil, excellent climate, many natural resources. What am I bid? Somalia is attractive to pirates because of its value to shipping.
The techniques are well-known. Establish an enclave. Vikings conquered. Carthaginians purchased. Many find abandoned land. Create a border. An impermeable border. Within the enclave establish fair laws justly enforced. Develop firm prejudices against corruption. The kingly way is only to allow the families of the original members and those they adopt. The utopian way is to only allow those in who are smart enough, or brave enough, or have found the revealed religion. The American way is to allow in those who agree with a written social contract. Accept civil rights, learn the language, swear to look after the other citizens as an extended family and you are in. These are important. If you cannot or will not talk out your problems from a common set of assumptions, then you have no society.
I hesitate to mention the repugnant Spartan method, but I must if only as a warning.It is one of the most common methods and the worst. Conquer a large area and then hold the inhabitants as helots or slaves. Before industrialisation it was tempting to keep others to do the hard and dangerous jobs. But it warps your society. In extreme cases it creates a ruling class that disdains work in favor of fighting. It teaches the young to be ruthless and cruel. Improvements are disincentivised. Spending so much time in the presence of the same sex warps even the sexuality of the rulers. And there is the continual knowledge that a rebellion of the helots is not only preordained, but also just. A resistance to change is fetishised as any change is liable to set off such a powder keg.
In any of these systems the rules are straight forward. Do not let in anyone whose religion says you are worth less and must be changed. Do not let in those who hate the society. Forbid those who condemn your lifestyles. Expel those who hate the ideas your new society is built upon. Don’t be too restrictive or your society will choke. Preserve people who argue civilly. Grow as fast as stability permits. Floreat! [I said straight forward, not easy.]
If your new society is good it will grow. If the society outside is corrupt your new state will expand. Expand the border with it. From such beginnings grew Rome and Carthage. If your new society doesn’t grow you are another failed state. And someone should try again.
A new imperialism seems needed. Refugees from these areas shouldn’t have to go far away to find order. And some of these countries deserve to die. Am I judging them? No. The processes of history and the actions of their own citizens have condemned them. Don’t look too much behind. They may be gaining on us.